TBO.com: Tampa Bay Online, The Tampa Tribune and The Tampa Times - breaking news and weather.
Tuesday, Sep 30, 2014
Movies

‘At Any Price' doesn't register


Published:

The flowing Iowa cornfields of “At Any Price” have nothing on the amber waves of Zac Efron's hair.‘Annoying Orange’ draws lawsuit A North Dakota advertising agency is suing the creators of a Cartoon Network show, alleging that they copied a state marketing campaign.

In “At Any Price,” Ramin Bahrani plants a sweeping Midwest tale of fathers and sons, fields and seed. His camera floats over cornfields listening to the rustling of the stalks, but the somewhat graceless stabs of grandeur in “At Any Price” don't register in this uneven but respectably ambitious heartland drama.H2M, a Fargo-based advertising and marketing agency, filed the lawsuit against Dane Boedigheimer and Spencer Grove, creators of the animated series “Annoying Orange.”

Dennis Quaid stars as Henry Whipple, an obsessively driven Iowa seed salesman, a family business he has inherited, along with constant pressure, from his overbearing father (Red West). Efron plays Henry's rebellious, race car-driving son Dean. (In the lengthy history of James Dean odes and references, this may well be the most overt.)H2M alleges Boedigheimer and Grove ripped off a copyrighted character called The Talking Orange that was created for television commercials for the North Dakota Department of Transportation. The commercials aired from 2005 to 2010.

Efron, a dashing screen presence making interesting choices for a heartthrob actor, attempts a classic American icon: a sweaty, sandy-haired, jean-wearing teenage trouble-maker. But the rebel role doesn't suit Efron: He doesn't have a lick of danger about him.The Talking Orange is comprised of an inanimate orange that has a superimposed mouth with lips, tongue and teeth. An actor's mouth speaking the character's part is composited onto the orange. It has a “snotty, annoying and slightly obnoxious” voice, which gives it an abrasive and abusive persona, the lawsuit stated.

In any case, this is Quaid's movie. He's not your father's farmer. His thousands of acres aren't pastoral, so much as the backdrop to the hulking modern machinery that drives his small empire, one fed by genetically modified seeds that he aggressively sells to other farmers.Boedigheimer and Grove are both North Dakota natives and attended college at Minnesota State University-Moorhead before relocating to California, the lawsuit said. Both still have family members in North Dakota and western Minnesota.

Early in the film, he and a reluctant Dean try to purchase land at a funeral. “Expand or die,” is Henry's manta.H2M is seeking damages, an injunction prohibiting Boedigheimer and Grove from profiting off their product.

But Henry is struggling to grow. A rival seed salesman (an excellent, easy Clancy Brown) is dwarfing his business. He also finds himself under investigation for selling used seeds, the authorities tipped off mysteriously.

His family life isn't much better. He's cheating on his wife Irene (Kim Dickens) with a younger woman (Heather Graham). His older, more loved son has abandoned him to travel in South America. Dean has no interest in the family business, though his girlfriend (Maika Monroe) begins accompanying him on visits to his customers.

Checking up-to-the-minute corn prices on his phone and glad-handing his customers with awkward folksy cheer, Quaid's Henry Whipple is part businessman, part politician and all huckster. He papers over the less noble sides of his life with forced smiles and strong-willed evasion, but his eyes give away his desperation. It's a strong if sometimes grating performance in need of less cliche-ridden dialogue.

Only after a flash of violence occurs (an implausibly setup moment in the screenplay co-written by Bahrani and Hallie Elizabeth Newton) does Henry glimpses the price of his relentless capitalism. (And, no, the metaphors aren't subtle.)

There's much to admire about “At Any Price,” with its seldom-seen portrait of men under financial, moral and corporate pressures. It can be applauded, too, for upending quaint notions of farm life in favor of a more realistic depiction of the modern agricultural industry.

But Bahrani, in his largest scale film yet and his first effort with big-name stars, seems to be wrestling with the balance of a more sizable production. His earlier indie films, like the simple but memorable “Man Push Car” (about the life of a Pakistani food cart seller in New York), show a depth of empathy.

When “At Any Price” draws to a crescendo, Dickon Hinchliffe's mournful score heavy-handedly signals the disturbing truths behind its characters' Midwest smiles and bright pastures. But the film hasn't quite earned the grim resonance it seeks. The harvest, begun with obviously good intentions, has been spoiled.

Subscribe to The Tampa Tribune

Comments